Home / Ukraine / How Russian Authorities Hijacked a WWII Remembrance Movement

How Russian Authorities Hijacked a WWII Remembrance Movement

On Victory Day, May 9, final year, a giant approach took over executive Moscow. Its participants hold aloft placards, with faded, black and white photographs of men and women, many of them in uniform, many of them somber, unsmiling. Crowds filled Moscow’s eight-lane executive avenue, Tverskaya Ulitsa, for a full 3 1/2 kilometers. On the same day, in hundreds of other cities, millions some-more marched with their possess photographs.

These were Russia’s “immortal regiments,” an homage to the era that mislaid some-more than 20 million people in the quarrel opposite the Nazis. The portraits people hold were of relatives who had lived and died during World War II.

The mood everywhere was of elation and national pride, as good as loss. But this wasn’t indispensably what a initial organizers had intended.


Four years earlier, a man called Igor Dmitriyev wrestled with his possess worries over Victory Day.

As a boy, Dmitriyev would symbol May 9 with his grandfather, who had fought his approach to Berlin and returned home, miraculously, to push forward with life. Each year, Dmitriyev’s family would accumulate around the table. Sometimes they would play the accordion and sing. There were some-more jokes about the war than discussions of its horrors.

When his grandfather died, Dmitriyev still sought the company of the World War II generation. On Victory day, a public holiday, he and his daughter would chose a veteran among the crowds. “It competence sound stupid, nonetheless we’d find a grandpa that we liked,” he says.

Then the aging veterans began to disappear. Unwilling to abandon their tradition, Dmitriyev and his daughter began to pick out other pensioners and military officials. But it didn’t feel right. He undetermined over the problem with friends in Tomsk, his Siberian hometown of half a million people. With fewer veterans, they thought, Victory Day had begun to lose a truth. From being an event of remembrance, it was quick apropos an official supervision party.

The friends motionless it was time to bring their grandparents back. “We suspicion a grandfathers should march,” Dmitriyev says in a gentle, relaxed voice. “Even if they were in our arms.”

He recruited dual friends operative at a internal radio hire in Tomsk, Sergei Lapenkov and Sergei Kolotovkin, to put out the word. They approaching a few hundred people to come to the initial imperishable ordain in 2012. Six thousand showed up.

RIA Novosti / Reuters

On May 9, 2015, people take partial in the Immortal Regiment impetus in Chita, in Siberia’s Zabaikalsky region.

The idea immediately valid infectious. News of the impetus by Tomsk spread, and people began job in from opposite Russia wanting to participate or classify their possess eventuality the following year. In 2013, imperishable regiments marched by 120 towns. A year later, they paraded nonetheless 500.

The founders set adult a website and wrote a charter. It admitted that the immortal ordain would perpetually sojourn a loose collection of volunteers; that it would be non-commercial, apolitical and non-state, and never be hijacked to improve anyone’s image. Its definition was simple: Help families remember their members who endured the war.


The purity of the transformation shortly done it vulnerable.

From the really start, the organizers were approached by politicians and corporate sponsors fervent to piggyback off their success. By the commencement of last year, they had begun to lose control. The main reason for this was Nikolai Zemtsov, a Communist Party emissary in Moscow’s internal parliament. Soon after creation hit with Dmitriyev, Lapenkov and Kolotovkin in 2013, Zemtsov began to insist that the immortal ordain in Moscow work with internal authorities for funding and organization.

When the Tomsk activists refused, Zemtsov went brute and set adult a copycat transformation called “The Immortal Regiment of Russia.”

Zemtsov did all the original organizers had wanted to avoid. He wanted on-stage speeches to the Moscow crowds. He fake links with domestic movements related to President Vladimir Putin. He canvassed for funding. He announced on television that imperishable regiments would impetus by Donetsk and Luhansk with “portraits not customarily of war veterans, nonetheless those who have died now, in the conflict opposite Ukrainian fascism.”

Zemtsov wrested control of last year’s impetus by Moscow. Afterward, his change widespread as he lobbied other cities opposite Russia to adopt his broker imperishable ordain as central organizer. Given their strange open proposal, there was small that the Tomsk founders could do to stop him.

Under Zemtsov’s direction, the movement in many cities now bears small propinquity to the apolitical prophesy mapped out in the strange charter. Organization committees have popped adult opposite the country, some sketch state salaries. Political parties and local authorities use imperishable ordain logos on their websites and in choosing pamphlets. Banks discharge placards with corporate logos. In schools opposite the country, children are tasked with creation placards and sent to march in groups.

Zemtsov defends all of this. He says the regiment’s founders were genuine to think hundreds of marches could be run by volunteers though a budget. “The organizers’ purpose is singular and they are needed, deliberation the scale of things,” he says.

But the original founders are questionable of Zemtsov’s motives. One of them, Sergei Lapenkov, says the people holding control of the ordain are destroying a concentration on personal family histories and on individuals. He says Zemtsov and those like him are posterior career enrichment and financial gain.

More fundamentally, he says, the takeover is about supervision holding control. All poignant antithesis parties, girl movements and NGOs have possibly been brought underneath the thumb or dejected during Putin’s reign. Here was an independent transformation that was expanding exponentially. “This contingency have severely disturbed somebody at the top,” says Lapenkov. “Someone thought: ‘What else competence these people do?'”


Lapenkov says “placard patriotism” is the inevitable outcome of bureaucrats removing concerned in voluntary endeavours. This kind of state-engineered nationalism has been abundant given the annexation of the Crimean Peninsula from Ukraine in 2014, and it reaches heat representation during the pageantry of Victory Day.

But it wasn’t always like this.

In the postwar decades, Victory Day was most quieter, and a family event. Veterans tended to avoid vocalization about the war. Lapenkov’s says his possess grandfather would never watch fight films (he mislaid both legs in the war, nonetheless following schooled to dance on his prostheses).

RIA Novosti / Reuters

President Vladimir Putin binds a portrait of his father, fight maestro Vladimir Spiridonovich Putin, while holding partial in the Immortal Regiment impetus on Red Square on May 9, 2015.

Victory Day was customarily overshadowed by May 1, Labor Day. It was in this jubilee of workers that the Communist Party invested some-more energy. Victory Day customarily became a public holiday with parades after 1965, underneath Leonid Brezhnev, with his supervision done from the fight generation.

After a lull following the collapse of the Soviet Union, the May 9 impetus was rehabilitated in 1995, on the 50th anniversary of victory. In a demoralized, damaged country, politicians fast saw Victory Day’s value as a uniting force, and made the parades an annual fixture. The final step came in 2008, when Putin reintroduced processions of tanks and intercontinental missiles opposite Red Square, a use mimicked on a smaller scale in cites opposite a country.

Alongside the rising resplendence of May 9, story itself has been created by the supervision to solidify a position. A mythologized chronicle of war intrepidity has emerged, reinforced by a solid upsurge of glossy state-subsidized nationalistic movies.

The immortal ordain plan directed to puncture that mythology and preserve genuine stories of personal loss. That thought survives on the founders’ strange website, moypolk.ru, that invites people to share their soldiers’ tales. In early May, there were 319,240 entries. “The stories are remarkable, infrequently wild,” says Dmitriyev. And often, they are touchingly unheroic.

One tells of a father who reported a day late to his dispatch station. For this failure, the man was placed in a “punishment battalion.” These battalions were most a death sentence — commanders used them for such tasks as using by minefields to clear them. That infantryman left though a trace, withdrawal his mother in lifelong mourning.

For some, not customarily the increased supervision control nonetheless the scale of the imperishable ordain risks undermining that humanity. This year’s eventuality promises to be the biggest yet. Regiments will impetus not customarily in hundreds of Russian cities, nonetheless in dozens of countries, including the United States, Spain and Indonesia.

That worries Nikita Petrov, a historian. “When this arrange of action becomes mass, it takes on a revanchist, quarrelsome character,” he says. “It is no longer personal remembrance, nonetheless a state event.”

Dmitriyev, the idea’s originator, is also anxious. “Everything this is now branch into is not right,” he says, “all of this classification and agreed numbers and times. Guys, stop, only stop. You’re all people. You all have grandfathers who fought. Let’s only remember them. Sometimes this turns into dancing on bones. Who needs it?” 

Article source: http://www.themoscowtimes.com/article/567938.html