Home / Sports / SEC 1, Harbaugh 0: Satellite camps are done, and we’re all worse off for it

SEC 1, Harbaugh 0: Satellite camps are done, and we’re all worse off for it

Whew. That was close.

It’s about time a SEC got a mangle in football.

In one of a all-time constructed controversies in college football, a SEC and ACC prevailed Friday by removing a NCAA Division we Council to anathema satellite camps. You know, those camps that supposing recruits comparatively inexpensive entrance to bearing with distinguished college football coaches to presumably get a vital scholarship. Who would wish that for players?

The whole debate, fueled by Jim Harbaugh’s artistic selling ideas and his enterprise to hang it to a SEC, was irritating from a start. Of all a issues in college football that we in a media chose to concentration so most on, satellite camps takes a cake as one of a slightest concrete since so most of a subject was fluff.

Coaches had opinions; we wrote them down. Over and over and over again. This was a go-to story whenever there were lifeless moments in college football, even nonetheless we don’t consider fans unequivocally cared that much.

And yes, we commend a irony of essay one final mainstay on this topic. In my America, you’re authorised to cranky mainstay borders.

Who cares if coaches spend their time perplexing to partisan players during off-campus camps instead of on-campus camps? And who’s to contend it’s unequivocally even that profitable to theatre these camps? Last we checked, Rutgers went 4-8 in 2015 and dismissed a manager notwithstanding carrying satellite camps by a years in Florida, Pennsylvania and Maryland.

To summation this stupid topic: Until now, NCAA manners settled that football programs could horde camps on their campus, inside their state or within a 50-mile radius of campus. The SEC and ACC don’t follow a NCAA sustenance that allows coaches to “guest coach” during another school’s stay to get around a 50-mile radius, so they successfully got a anathema on all satellite camps.

“The Council authorized a offer germane to a Football Bowl Subdivision that would need those schools to control camps and clinics during their schools comforts or during comforts frequently used for use or competition,” a NCAA pronounced in a statement. “Additionally, FBS coaches and non-coaching staff members with responsibilities specific to football competence be employed usually during their school’s camps or clinics. This order change is effectively immediately.”

So long, “Summer Swarm Tour.”

We frequency knew you, shirtless Jim Harbaugh.

In new years, many schools have reason satellite camps, such as Notre Dame, Penn State, Oklahoma and Oklahoma State. But Harbaugh took a use to a new turn final summer by rarely publicizing a 10-day, seven-state stay tour in Pennsylvania, Indiana, Alabama, Florida, Texas, California and Michigan. He was formulation another discuss in Jun with stay stops in Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia and Texas.

The SEC’s position opposite satellite camps was injured from a beginning. For starters, a SEC portrayed satellite camps as awful “recruiting camps,” as if on-campus summer camps are reason by SEC coaches simply to learn fundamentals to players, some of whom occur to be of high propagandize age and who competence find their proceed into a coach’s bureau with a grant offer. Please.

“Calling them satellite camps is a sum misnomer,” LSU jaunty executive Joe Alleva pronounced during a SEC open meetings final year. “They’re not satellite camps. They’re quite and simply recruiting camps.”

Of march they are. So? Who’s being spoiled if under-the-radar players get a small some-more bearing to high-profile coaches around a country?

The SEC, that’s who. Or during slightest that was a SEC’s fear, even nonetheless it’s substantially misguided. The SEC enjoys strenuous recruiting advantages: so many gifted recruits in their footprint, comfortable weather, NFL breeze picks, media exposure, on-field success, wild fan bases and a ton of money. Those luxuries aren’t unexpected disintegrating if Harbaugh spends one day in Prattville, Alabama.

This was Alleva final open to 104.5 FM ESPN in Baton Rouge: “Mainly what I’m endangered about is other schools coming into a state and hidden a kids.”

That has always been a crux of a emanate for a SEC. (Sidenote: we didn’t know LSU owns all of a recruits in Louisiana to systematise one withdrawal a state as theft, though indicate duly noted.)

Jim Harbaugh is substantially not going to be happy about a NCAA’s decision. (USATSI)

“I’m unequivocally not even meditative that it has that most value,” Alabama manager Nick Saban told reporters this week about satellite camps. “What would be a some-more engaging doubt for we to investigate — and we can’t answer this — a teams that have finished them, what value does it serve? How many players did they get? They had some players dedicate to them and some of those players decommitted, and we know they even wanted to dump some of those players when they found out they could get improved players.”

Saban isn’t wrong. For Alabama, a satellite stay expected wouldn’t have done most sense. Saban can already collect and select from roughly any partisan in a country. For another school, such as Michigan, it competence be profitable to try to get a foothold in a opposite partial of a country. Or it competence not. But there’s no mistreat trying.

Here’s a question: Why do some schools play neutral-site games? They have a vast campus stadium. They have fans in a village peaceful to attend games during pronounced vast campus stadium. And nonetheless once a year we play a game, such as Alabama vs. Michigan, inside an NFL architecture in Arlington, Texas. Why? It’s a good payday and good recruiting exposure.

As for Saban’s investigate request, recruiting analysts have pronounced they don’t see most of an impact for schools with satellite camps. Michigan sealed 3 players in Feb who attended a satellite camp. Rashad Weaver, who was speckled by Harbaugh during a Miami satellite camp, decommitted from Michigan since he pronounced a coaches stopped hit with him and he didn’t perspective himself as a Plan B.

So to sum adult Harbaugh’s initial satellite stay experience: He sealed a few players, got a lot of cinema taken with no shirt on, and combined a whole lot of headaches from a bad PR of recruiting over a actor he found during a camp. Talk about an astray recruiting advantage!

One of a biggest concerns settled about satellite camps was proliferation. Some coaches understandably wish to have lives in a summer. (Yes, a state of college sports is such that we contingency order so coaches can have lives in a summer.) There were also concerns about a costs and time concerned for recruits if a camps kept growing.

The NCAA: Where time-demand issues get legislated on players before they’re even in college. Once you’re in school? You know a drill: Only 20 hours per week spent on football (wink, wink; nod, nod).

The Pac-12 indeed had one of a some-more engaging ideas to get around a satellite stay debate. The discussion suggested staging informal combines for recruits around a nation any summer. It sounds like that thought didn’t get unequivocally far.

Perhaps a biggest smirch of a SEC’s evidence was a fact that many of a coaches wish to do them. Georgia’s Kirby Smart, Texas AM’s Kevin Sumlin and Arkansas’ Bret Bielema were among those on record observant they were prepared to theatre camps if a NCAA anathema didn’t happen.

Bielema told ESPN he was going to do an disdainful stay with a Dallas Cowboys that no one else in a SEC will do. He has also talked about going East with a Big Ten team.

“When we initial got here, we was vacant during a restrictions a SEC puts on ourselves,” Bielema told ESPN. “Not being means to go to camps, not being means to go to clinics, not being means to have your staff be benefaction during in-state clinics that are your home base. We do so many things, so many parameters that extent a recruiting base, that is good in some regards, though it boundary a branding.”

Harbaugh and Ohio State’s Urban Meyer both announced skeleton for satellite camps in Georgia this summer. Smart recently told reporters a Bulldogs designed to reason their possess if allowed. “I consider it’s unequivocally intelligent on their part. They’ve got a right to do it,” Smart said. “Like we said, we’ve got a devise ready. You’ll see shortly enough.”

Texas AM manager Kevin Sumlin told ESPN a Aggies had indeterminate satellite camps set on a calendar. “We’re not a usually SEC group that’s doing that, too,” Sumlin said.

The SEC became a walking contradiction. While a joining pushed to anathema these awful recruiting camps, some of a SEC’s possess coaches were unequivocally meddlesome in entertainment these awful recruiting camps. Enough conferences concluded with a SEC’s altogether position, so instead of perplexing to umpire satellite camps with a totalled approach, they criminialized them altogether.

Any day now, we design Michigan to find a loophole by announcing it’s building satellite campuses in Alabama, Florida and Georgia, so permitting “on-campus” football camps in Miami. Because really, who wouldn’t wish to attend a University of Michigan during Miami?

There are lessons schooled from this satellite stay debate. In Harbaugh’s America, you’re authorised to cranky state borders. In a SEC’s America, there are snipers lerned during a border.

Or something like that. That’s how narratives go.

We’re all dumber for carrying spent so most time on where teenagers attend summer football camps.

The SEC gets their way, again. (USATSI)

Article source: http://www.cbssports.com/collegefootball/writer/jon-solomon/25547256/ncaa-puts-an-end-to-silly-satellite-camp-debate-but-hurts-players-most